China’s foreign ministry on Tuesday dismissed accusations that boats belonging to a Chinese maritime militia had deliberately approached an area of the South China Sea where the navies of Indian and ASEAN countries were holding drills.
An independent expert in Vietnam said Beijing appeared to be using the militia to intimidate and disrupt the naval exercise.
“As far as we understand, Chinese fishing and scientific research vessels carry out normal production and work activities in maritime areas under China’s jurisdiction,” China’s foreign ministry said in response to Reuters’s request for comments.
“The outside world should not make groundless accusations or make trouble out of nothing,” the ministry added.
The Indian and Vietnamese governments have declined to comment.
The two-day sea phase of the ASEAN-India Maritime Exercise (AIME 2023) began on Sunday with naval ships and aircraft from India, Vietnam, Thailand, the Philippines, Indonesia and Brunei taking part.
They were in the Vietnamese Exclusive Economic Zone when the Chinese boats moved towards them, the Indian sources said. However, the militia boats and naval vessels crossed each other without any face-off, they said.
Indian authorities were tracking the movements of at least five militia boats, according to the sources, who did not wish to be identified as they are not authorized to speak to the media.
A Chinese research vessel was also following these boats towards the same area, they said.
Ray Powell, who leads Project Myoushu on the South China Sea at Stanford University, said the boats belong to the Qiong Sansha Yu militia fleet in the area.
Such militias consist of commercial fishing boats, which work in coordination with the Chinese authorities for political objectives in the South China Sea. The Chinese government, however, in the past rejected the existence of any such militia.
Van Pham, manager of The South China Sea Chronicle Initiative (SCSCI), an independent non-profit which monitors vessel-tracking data, said this was not the first time Chinese “so-called fishing vessels” were around and intimidated warships of other countries.
“So it’s likely that the exercise was interrupted…the pattern was broken and some had to change their directions,” she told Reuters.
Chinese research vessel Xiang Yang Hong 10 had come as close as 10 miles to the participating Vietnamese warship at one point, Pham said.
The drill is the first ASEAN-India Maritime Exercise (AIME-2023) and is co-hosted by the Indian and Singaporean navies.
Several of China’s littoral neighbors have accused it of using its official and militia vessels to harass and intimidate their fishing and military boats in the South China Sea.
China has for years claimed sovereignty over the entire South China Sea, and has been sensitive to the presence of other militaries in the region.
Relations between India and China have also plummeted since a clash between their armies in the Himalayas in 2020 in which 24 soldiers were killed.